<< return difference WebPack and embedded bundler in Angular
| moduleResolution Value | Description | Suitable for | Potential Issues | Notes for Angular/Electron |
| "node" | Uses Node.js's module resolution algorithm. Prioritizes node_modules and follows a well-defined search path. | Most JavaScript projects, especially those using npm or yarn; often used in Electron main processes. | Can be less predictable if project structure deviates from Node.js conventions. May lead to issues if not correctly configured with a bundler. | Generally preferred for the Electron main process (but still needs careful consideration with the bundler). |
| "classic" | Uses a simpler, older strategy. Resolves modules based on file system paths relative to the current file. | Small, simple projects. Generally avoided in any modern project using modules. | Highly unreliable in larger projects or projects with complex dependency structures. Prone to errors and inconsistencies. | Should never be used in an Angular project or an Electron project. |
| "bundler" | Assumes a module bundler (like Webpack or Vite) is handling module resolution. TypeScript defers resolution to the bundler's capabilities. | Modern JavaScript projects that definitely use a module bundler, including Angular projects and often Electron renderer processes. | Requires proper bundler configuration. Errors might occur if the bundler isn't configured correctly or isn't actually used. | Often the best choice for Angular within the Electron renderer process (but it needs a correctly configured Angular CLI & bundler configuration). |
moduleResolution: "bundler" requires ES Modules: The bundler setting instructs the TypeScript compiler to resolve modules according to the Node.js module resolution mechanism. This resolution mechanism is designed to work with ECMAScript modules (ESM) ("module": "ES2022", "ES2015", "ESNext", etc.) or when "module" is set to "preserve".
For any non-trivial Electron project (especially with Angular, which relies on modern JavaScript features), the best approach is to use a module bundler like Webpack or esbuild, or another supported tool by Angular like Rollup, Parcel, or Vite, or even just use the embedded bundler. Webpack or any similar tool allows you to use es modules directly ("module": "ESNext" / "ES2022" or other modern ES module types). More about Webpack Webpack note about Angular Electron.
Difference between Angular bundler and Webpack:
- • "moduleResolution": "bundler" (in tsconfig.json): This compiler option only affects how the TypeScript compiler (tsc) resolves module imports (finds the corresponding files). It tells tsc to use the Node.js module resolution algorithm. This algorithm will locate files specified by relative paths, package names and file extensions. This is important for resolving ES module imports typically found and used in modern Javascript frontend projects.
- • Webpack (or other bundlers): Webpack is a module bundler. Its primary job is to take multiple JavaScript modules (and other assets like CSS, images, etc.) and bundle them into a smaller number of optimized files suitable for a browser or other runtime environments. It resolves modules too. This is done automatically and it is one of the reasons why module bundlers are a much better choice for larger projects where lots of files and external modules need to be imported. Webpack resolves module imports automatically. Bundlers handle tree shaking, where unused parts of the Javascript code are removed before bundling the code in production mode, as well as handles many different web asset file types. Bundlers also enable a number of optimization techniques to reduce the output size such as minification of JavaScript code and optimization of image sizes. They also support hot module replacement (HMR).
Key Differences and why Webpack (or a similar tool), In short: "moduleResolution": "bundler" helps the TypeScript compiler find modules using node's resolution algorithm but it doesn't bundle, optimize, handle non-typescript web assets, tree shaking, minification, and so on. These tasks are handled by Webpack or other bundlers and are usually crucial for a production-ready Angular application. While you can technically make an Angular application without a bundler using the Angular compiler, this approach is strongly discouraged because of limitations related to these features, and the resulting code will not be suitable for production use and bundle sizes will be much larger without using a bundler. Module resolution in itself is not enough.
| Feature "moduleResolution": | "bundler" | Webpack (or similar bundler) |
| Module Resolution | Yes (using Node's algorithm) | Yes (various algorithms/configs) |
| Bundling/Code SplittiIn | No | Yes |
| Optimization (tree-shaking, minification, etc.) | No | Yes |
| Asset Handling (CSS, images, etc.) | No | Yes |
| Development Server (HMR) | No | Yes (usually included/configurable) |
| Plugin Ecosystem | No | Yes (very extensive) |
The bundler handles the module resolution and creates optimized bundles, which is much more efficient and maintainable for Electron apps than trying to bundle with outFile. Using Webpack with Angular is often the de-facto standard and the suggested way by Angular itself and should resolve all issues associated with outFile, especially when creating more complex Electron and Angular applications.
If you're committed to using tsc without a bundler for a simple project, then "System" is generally the better module option to use with outFile as discussed. But consider switching to a bundler to avoid the limitations of outFile and gain the advantages of better module handling and optimization, as well as not being constrained by which module format you choose.
Two most common TSC error message (more about Tsc options Tsc Compiler "Module" and "outFile/outDir" Options):
- • TS5095: Option 'bundler' can only be used when 'module' is set to 'preserve' or to 'es2015' or later: This indicates that the bundler module resolution setting in your base tsconfig.json is incompatible with "module": "CommonJS" which is inherited from your base tsconfig in your tsconfig.electron.json.
- • TS6082: Only 'amd' and 'system' modules are supported alongside --outFile: This error, appearing twice, reinforces that if you are using the outFile option to bundle the output, you cannot use "module": "CommonJS". With outFile, you must use "module": "System" or "module": "AMD".
Angular options Angular Options
)
|
|